Get Your Paid Social Campaigns Back on the Right Track
So, you started your advertising on Facebook and Instagram a few years ago and everything was great! Folks were engaging with your ads, going to your landing page and filling out your forms. Then something happened; competitors found the hidden gem that is paid social media, Facebook started making algorithm adjustments and eliminating interest-based targeting that we found helpful in identifying prospective students. Performance dropped and we all lost faith in the platform.
But there is hope! ES is here to walk you through some optimizations that will get your Facebook and Instagram paid campaigns back on the right track!
Targeting
Interest-based targeting seems to be the default targeting method that we see in most campaigns we audit. It seems logical to figure out what your prospective students are interested in and then target those behaviors, interests, and demographics. But there is another way…
What we at Edwards Strategies have found to be even more successful is lookalike targeting. Lookalike targeting is basically taking a list of your current students’ or enrollments’ email addresses and upload them to Facebook to create a custom audience. Facebook then takes that custom audience and identifies common qualities among those people (demographic info or interests). Then Facebook finds people who are similar to them.
We’ve found lookalike audiences to be most effective when parsing them out by program. Each program’s students will look different, so splitting them up that way will give you a clearer picture. Lookalike audiences have produced double digit percentage improvements in lead volume and CPL.
Messaging
Each program is different. And the demographics of the students for each program will vary as well. That means your messaging has to be tailored specifically to the prospective students in each program you are trying to reach. For instance, if you student demo skews 18-25 and female, that’s who you need to speak to in your copy and represent in your photos and or videos. This seems simple but we see this detail missed in so many campaigns.
Capturing
When Facebook first launched their ad platform, it was all about sending traffic off of the platform and to a landing page where you hoped people would fill out your contact form. In the last couple of years Facebook has introduced forms on their platform so interested users can fill out a form for more information without ever having to leave the Facebook platform.
While there have been some hiccups in this process (large amounts of spammy submissions), Facebook has taken steps to improve the quality of inquiries they are generating. One of the main ways they have improved the quality is by introducing two-step form confirmation.
Testing
In order to get the most out of your paid social campaigns, you should always be testing different elements of your ads. From the types of pictures you are using to the copy in your headline or in the body, there is always opportunity to improve performance. Here are a few tests that we have recently run:
- Stock photos vs. real company photos
- Headline test:
- “Classes Start Soon” vs specific start dates
- Open House Dates
- Display URL
- Generic vs Program-specific
- Ad Copy
- Generic vs Program-specific
- No location vs including location
These are just a few examples of where you can start your testing process.
Following these optimizations should help improve the performance of your paid social campaigns and get the back on the right track. If you need any help making these optimizations, you can reach out to us at Edwards Strategies here.

About the Author EdwardsSchoen
Situated in the heart of Kansas City - the land of barbecue, jazz, and Chiefs football - EdwardsSchoen works with clients across the U.S. on everything from marketing planning and execution to training and performance, consulting to research opportunities. Our focus is on aligning your goals and strategies to a dynamic, ever-changing marketplace. We work hard, adapt quickly, and make it a point of pride to deliver tangible results.
This entry was posted on Tuesday, August 6th, 2019 at 6:02 pm and is filed under Digital Marketing, Paid Marketing, Social Media. You can follow any responses to this entry through the RSS 2.0 feed. Both comments and pings are currently closed.
Recent Posts by EdwardsSchoen
If Animals Had Spring Break, Here’s What They’d Do
April 21, 2025 | Getting Off Track
Spring break: the legendary time of year when humans migrate en masse …
Navigating the Labor Shortage for Home Service Businesses
April 18, 2025 | Industry News
The labor shortage isn’t new, but for home service businesses, the challenge …
6 Tips for Engaging Prospective Students on Social
April 10, 2025 | Social Media
What Works and What Doesn’t When You’re Trying to Build Connections Millions …
Google Ads vs. Facebook Ads and What to Use
April 8, 2025 | Paid Marketing
When it comes to digital marketing, two platforms dominate the landscape: Google …
The Benefits of Marketing Automation
April 2, 2025 | Digital Marketing
Marketing automation has become a powerful tool for businesses looking to maximize …
Smart Home Integration Opportunities for Home Service Providers
March 31, 2025 | Industry News
Smart home technology has evolved dramatically over the past decade, transforming from …